Who Should Be In The 2014 MLB All-Star Game?

I already know that people are going to have a problem with who I selected. It’s unavoidable. I’m not saying that my list is perfect, It’s as close as I believe I could get as to get everyone deserving into an All-Star game. I like to see players in the game that deserve it. Who have had a great 2014 thus far. I care nothing about what you’ve done in the past, what your legacy is, etc. If you’ve played like an all-star in 2014, you deserve to represent your ballclub.

To stay within the realistic expectations, I picked 34 guys & made sure that every team had representation. I also gave myself strict requirements within these rules.

Each team has 34 players. 6 outfield, 3 catchers, 12 infielders (3 at each infield position), 13 pitchers. This was tougher than I thought. Welp, enough chatter….



Felix Hernandez

Masahiro Tanaka

Chris Sale

Scott Kazmir

Garrett Richards

Yu Darvish

David Price

Jon Lester

Dallas Keuchel

Koji Uehara

Dellin Betances

Greg Holland

Zach Britton


Edwin Encarnacion

Jose Altuve

Jose Abreu

Victor Martinez

Ian Kinsler

Josh Donaldson

Brian Dozier

Alexei Ramirez

Adrian Beltre

Kyle Seager

Alcides Escobar

Erick Aybar

Yeah, I know. No Miggy, Cano or Brandon Moss. Between Altuve having a ridiculous 1st half and Dozier being the best player on the Twins so far & them needing a rep, cuts had to be made. When it came down to first basemen, It was between V-Mart & Miggy.  Victor’s got the better average, more homers, better OBP, better OPS. It’s all close, but if I had to choose, I’m going V-Mart.


Mike Trout

Nelson Cruz

Michael Brantley

Jose Bautista

Adam Jones

Melky Cabrera


Salvador Perez

Derek Norris

Yan Gomes



Johnny Cueto

Adam Wainwright

Julio Teheran

Clayton Kershaw

Zack Greinke

Josh Beckett

Jason Hammel

Madison Bumgarner

Alfredo Simon

Francisco Rodriguez

Craig Kimbrel

Huston Street

Rafael Soriano


Troy Tulowitzki

Paul Goldschmidt

Todd Frazier

Dee Gordon

Anthony Rendon

Anthony Rizzo

Freddie Freeman

Daniel Murphy

Hanley Ramirez

Starlin Castro

Matt Carpenter

Casey McGehee


Giancarlo Stanton

Carlos Gomez

Andrew McCutchen

Charlie Blackmon

Yasiel Puig

Marlon Byrd


Jonathan Lucroy

Devin Mesoraco

Evan Gattis

I know that Gattis is on the DL but I’m not choosing injury replacements. If I had to, it’d be Posey. 

In conclusion, the one player per team rule’s gotta go. It would’ve made this a lot easier. It also would’ve been easier if I could take like 6 first basemen on each squad. My teams aren’t perfect, but I stand by them. Go ahead, rip them apart. I’d love to hear you think I missed. Seriously. Comment below or hit me up on Twitter @sideleague.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s